In short. ComfyUI is a node-based interface, best for repeatable workflows and API use. AUTOMATIC1111 is the classic all-in-one Stable Diffusion WebUI, with a familiar tabbed layout and a large extension library. InvokeAI is a polished creative studio built around a canvas. All three run on a GPU VPS, so check each project’s current maintenance status before you commit.
Choosing a Stable Diffusion interface feels like a matter of taste until you host it. Then it becomes a question about maintenance and API access, and about what happens when a new model ships next month. ComfyUI vs AUTOMATIC1111 is the argument you see most often, with InvokeAI as the third option for people who want a canvas instead of a graph. This comparison covers how the three differ and how to run them safely in Docker behind a login, including the VRAM each model family needs.
ComfyUI vs AUTOMATIC1111 vs InvokeAI at a glance
ComfyUI wins on automation, AUTOMATIC1111 on familiarity, and InvokeAI on image editing. ComfyUI vs InvokeAI is mostly a choice between a graph and a canvas, and the table shows where each tool differs.
| Dimension | ComfyUI | AUTOMATIC1111 | InvokeAI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interface style | Node graph | Tabbed web form | Canvas and gallery studio |
| Learning curve | Steep | Gentle | Gentle to moderate |
| Workflow and API | Workflows saved as JSON, REST and WebSocket API built in | Form-based, no saved graph | Canvas-based, gallery for results |
| Extension ecosystem | Custom nodes | Largest legacy extension library | Fewer add-ons, more built in |
| Model support | SD 1.5, SDXL, Flux, Wan 2.2 and more | SD 1.5 and SDXL | SD 1.5, SDXL, FLUX.1, Wan 2.2 |
| Best for | Automation, video, shared workflows | Existing SD 1.5 and SDXL setups | Creative editing, inpainting |
What is ComfyUI?
ComfyUI is an open-source, node-based interface for image and video generation. You build a workflow by wiring nodes together instead of filling in a form, and every workflow is a graph you can save as JSON and rerun with different inputs. That repeatability is its main strength.
The ComfyUI server is also the API. It runs as an HTTP server by default, so any working install already accepts calls over REST and WebSocket. A practical example: a script posts a saved workflow with a new prompt and collects the finished image, with no browser involved. For a concrete workflow on this stack, the Wan 2.2 video generation guide with ComfyUI walks through a full install and an end-to-end video setup, so this article skips the install steps.
When to choose ComfyUI
Verdict: the default for a hosted server. Best for: automation and API use, plus video models and shared workflows. Not ideal for: anyone who wants to type a prompt and press a button on day one. The learning curve is steep, and the graph looks like a circuit board for the first few evenings.
What is AUTOMATIC1111 (Stable Diffusion WebUI)?
AUTOMATIC1111 is the classic all-in-one Stable Diffusion WebUI: a browser form with tabs for text-to-image, image-to-image, and inpainting, plus a very large extension library. It launched in 2022 and defined what a self-hosted Stable Diffusion interface looks like.
Maintenance is the thing to check before you commit. The most recent tagged release is v1.10.1 (a small bug-fix release, February 2025 per GitHub’s release page). It supports SD 1.5, SDXL and SD3 but not newer models like Flux. Check commit activity on GitHub before building on it. If you already have a library of extensions and prompts around SD 1.5 or SDXL, it still works. For a new deployment, start with ComfyUI, or Forge Neo if you want a similar UI on NVIDIA hardware.
When to choose AUTOMATIC1111
Verdict: a safe choice only for existing setups. Best for: SD 1.5 and SDXL work with extensions you already depend on. Not ideal for: new deployments or anything you plan to automate.
What is InvokeAI?
InvokeAI is an open-source creative studio built around a unified canvas for inpainting, outpainting, and layered editing, with a gallery for managing results. Its PyPI listing shows an Apache license and Python 3.11 or 3.12 as requirements, and the project documentation lists support for SD 1.5, SDXL, FLUX.1, and Wan 2.2 on NVIDIA GPUs. Check the current edition and licensing terms before you plan a team deployment.
When to choose InvokeAI
Verdict: the best fit for people who edit images rather than script them. Best for: artists and small teams working on a canvas. Not ideal for: large automated pipelines or anyone who needs the biggest extension library.
Stable Diffusion VRAM requirements on a GPU VPS
Most Stable Diffusion models need between 4 GB and 12 GB of VRAM at minimum, and a 96 GB GPU clears every row below with room for batching. The figures come from the InvokeAI hardware documentation. Treat them as a floor, because higher resolutions and larger batches raise them and quantized variants lower them.
| Model family | Minimum VRAM | Handled by |
|---|---|---|
| SD 1.5 | 4 GB | ComfyUI, AUTOMATIC1111, InvokeAI |
| SDXL | 8 GB | ComfyUI, AUTOMATIC1111, InvokeAI |
| FLUX.1 | 10 GB | ComfyUI, InvokeAI |
| Wan 2.2 TI2V-5B | 8 GB | ComfyUI, InvokeAI |
| Wan 2.2 A14B | 12 GB with Q4_K_M quantization | ComfyUI, InvokeAI |
Video is where VRAM stops being a footnote, because higher quality settings and longer clips push requirements well past the floor. If you are still comparing hardware across providers, the GPU hosting for Stable Diffusion comparison covers the options.
Running ComfyUI, AUTOMATIC1111 and InvokeAI in Docker
All three run in Docker on a GPU VPS as long as the host has the NVIDIA driver and the NVIDIA Container Toolkit installed. A ComfyUI Docker setup has one catch: the project ships no official Docker image, and the ComfyUI docs say community images are not maintained or supported by the ComfyUI team. A short Dockerfile you control is the safer route.
- ComfyUI: build your own image and start the server with
python main.py --listen 0.0.0.0 --port 8188. Mount the models and output folders as volumes so a rebuild never deletes your checkpoints. - AUTOMATIC1111: an AUTOMATIC1111 Docker container follows the same pattern. The web UI listens on port 7860 by default, and you need the
--listenflag for access from outside the container. - InvokeAI: keep its root directory on a volume and publish the web port shown in its startup log.
A minimal Compose file for ComfyUI binds the port to loopback, so a reverse proxy is the only way in:
services:
comfyui:
build: .
command: python main.py --listen 0.0.0.0 --port 8188
ports:
- "127.0.0.1:8188:8188"
volumes:
- ./models:/app/models
- ./output:/app/output
deploy:
resources:
reservations:
devices:
- driver: nvidia
count: all
capabilities: [gpu]
The /app paths assume your Dockerfile sets that working directory. Adjust them to match.
Where Forge WebUI fits in
Forge WebUI is the Stable Diffusion WebUI derivative for people who like the tabbed interface but need newer models. Forge Neo, a community fork by Haoming02 under the AGPL-3.0 license, continues the Forge line. Its GitHub page lists Flux.2 Klein, Qwen-Image, Z-Image, and Wan 2.2 (14B only), and it listens on port 7860 by default.
Choose Forge Neo if you want A1111-style tabs on current models. Skip it if API automation matters more.
ComfyUI server: multi-user access and API use
A ComfyUI server has no authentication by default, so a public instance needs a reverse proxy with authentication in front of it. The ComfyUI docs say so directly. Four rules keep it safe:
- Keep ComfyUI on loopback and publish it only through a proxy such as Nginx, with HTTPS and a login.
- Do not treat
--multi-useras access control. It enables per-user storage, not authentication. - Pin your ComfyUI version. The raw REST and WebSocket API has no compatibility guarantee across releases.
- Handle AUTOMATIC1111 and InvokeAI the same way: keep them on loopback and expose them through the same authenticated proxy.
Never expose any of these UIs to the internet without a login. Each one can run arbitrary workflows on your GPU.
Which Stable Diffusion UI to host: ComfyUI, AUTOMATIC1111 or InvokeAI?
Host ComfyUI unless you have a specific reason not to. The exceptions are short:
- Automation and API use: ComfyUI. Its workflows are JSON files and its server is already an API.
- Familiar tabs and existing extensions: AUTOMATIC1111 for an SD 1.5 or SDXL library you already have, Forge Neo for current models.
- A creative studio with canvas editing: InvokeAI.
- A newcomer who wants results this afternoon: InvokeAI or Forge Neo first, then ComfyUI once the basics click.
You can also run more than one. On a 96 GB card, each tool gets its own container and port behind one proxy.
Why run image generation on a Contabo GPU VPS
A Contabo GPU VPS is a virtual server with a dedicated NVIDIA GPU, billed at a flat monthly rate. The current plan pairs an RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell Server Edition with 96 GB of GDDR7 ECC VRAM, 18 vCPUs, 96 GB of RAM, and 900 GB of NVMe storage for €999 per month excluding VAT, with 15% off on a 12-month term and 20% off on 24 months. Availability is limited to the EU and US Central regions during the initial run. Check the GPU VPS product page for current pricing and availability.
That is more GPU than SD 1.5 or SDXL need for one person. It pays off when you run ComfyUI and a second UI side by side, generate Wan 2.2 video, or serve a team from one box.
FAQ: ComfyUI, AUTOMATIC1111 and InvokeAI
Is ComfyUI better than AUTOMATIC1111?
ComfyUI is better for automation, newer models, and repeatable workflows. AUTOMATIC1111 is better only if you want a familiar tabbed form or already depend on its extensions. ComfyUI exposes an HTTP API by default and supports newer models such as Flux and Wan 2.2. The tradeoff is a steeper learning curve, so budget a few evenings.
Is AUTOMATIC1111 (Stable Diffusion WebUI) still maintained?
Check the GitHub releases page for the current status, because maintenance changes quickly. The most recent tagged release found during research is v1.10.1. AUTOMATIC1111 still runs SD 1.5 and SDXL workflows. For new projects, consider Forge Neo, which keeps a similar tabbed interface on newer models, or ComfyUI, which supports the widest range of current models.
Can I run ComfyUI in Docker on a GPU VPS?
Yes. Install the NVIDIA driver and the NVIDIA Container Toolkit on the host, then run ComfyUI from an image you build yourself, because the project has no official Docker image. Start the server with `–listen 0.0.0.0 –port 8188`, bind the published port to loopback, reserve the GPU in Compose, and put an authenticated reverse proxy in front.
How much VRAM do I need for Stable Diffusion?
According to the InvokeAI documentation, SD 1.5 needs at least 4 GB of VRAM, SDXL 8 GB, and FLUX.1 10 GB. Wan 2.2 video models need 8 GB for the 5B variant and 12 GB for the A14B variant with Q4_K_M quantization. Larger resolutions and batches need more, so treat these numbers as minimums, not targets.
What is the difference between ComfyUI and InvokeAI?
ComfyUI is a node-graph tool built for repeatable workflows and API automation. InvokeAI is a canvas-based creative studio built for inpainting, outpainting, and layered editing. Both support SDXL, FLUX.1, and Wan 2.2. Pick ComfyUI when you want to script and share pipelines, and InvokeAI when you want to edit images by hand.
